It was a big mistake to migrate my Nest account to a Google Assistant account.
Almost a year ago, Google announced that it did Works with Nest program ends, At the time, I was able to use the Nest Learning Thermostat's home and away status to automate a number of my smart home devices. For example, if I left my house and the thermostat went into vacation mode, I could use Works with Nest to turn off my Philips Hue lights, turn on security systems, and more.
I could also use other smart home devices to automatically control the Nest thermostat. If I activated a night scene in the Lutron app – turn off the lights and close the blinds – the app would also command the thermostat to lower the temperature.
Don't switch your Nest account!
If you Move your Nest account into a Google Assistant account – like me – everything that's gone, and Google still has to replace this functionality. In an interview with Tom & # 39; s Guide last November, Michele Turner, senior director of Google's smart home ecosystem, said some of these features would be available in early 2020, but I'm still waiting.
If you have a smart home targeted at Google Home, currently you can only control smart home devices by speaking a sentence to a smart speaker activated by Google Assistant or by creating a Google Home routine that will be activated at a specific time should. And that is far behind the competition.
Where Alexa (and even Apple HomeKit) beat Google
One of the best smart home integrations was the Nest Protect smoke detector. If I had a Nest account, I could link the Nest Protect to my Philips Hue lights so that when the smoke alarm went off, all my lights came on, making it easier for my family and me to escape if there was a fire. Not only is this no longer available, you cannot connect the Nest Protect to anything in Google Assistant. Not only is it less functional, it is also less secure.
In contrast, Alexa This option allows you to control smart home devices when your phone enters or leaves an area, when an Alexa speaker hears broken glass or a fire alarm, when a motion or door sensor is triggered, or when a surveillance camera detects motion.
Despite its other shortcomings, Apple’s HomeKit offers similar functions. The light can also be switched on automatically when a smoke detector is activated. In addition to automating smart home devices based on whether you are arriving or leaving, you can create automation based on any location you want.
Let's say I'm on a business trip. I can program HomeKit to turn on a certain light as soon as Apple detects my phone at my destination and turn that light off after a certain amount of time.
Google's homepage must soon become more intelligent
Since I'm responsible for all of Tom & # 39; s Guide's smart home categories, I've set up Alexa, Google Assistant and HomeKit in my house. I generally don't use any of the voice assistants unless I want to play music or turn on the lights. I don't want to have to say "Siri" or "Alexa" or "Hey, Google". I want things to happen without having to say it. Currently, Amazon and Apple are way ahead of Google in creating a truly automated smart home.
Because of its farsightedness, Nest had an early smart home advantage. Unfortunately, Google Home not only lacks the capabilities of Alexa and HomeKit, but Google has not yet replicated Nest's functions. Google has promised us it will come soon, but how long do we have to wait?