Labour in Wales need to wake up to fact that Westminster is no longer the route to socialism

Keir Starmer, the new leader of Labor.

Tim Richards

Probably the most bizarre and revealing story about last December's general election was that the Labor party brought its activists from Liverpool to the Arfon constituency held by Plaid Cymru.

On the way there, it bypassed several marginal labor places near its home, such as Wrexham.

If Plaid Cymru's deputy Hywel Williams had been a horrible right-wing nationalist who might have been understandable, but if they had actually checked his file on the They Work For You website, they would have found a poll on important issues that this would please the vast majority of Labor supporters.

As a result of this terrible campaign, Hywel Williams naturally increased its majority, and Labor lost to the conservatives except for one "red wall" of seats in north Wales.

In fact, Boris Johnson's success was so great that many traditional Labor seats in the north of England switched loyalty to the Tories because they believed in Brexit and the essence of English nationalism.

And despite the Covid-19 pandemic that damages Johnson's credibility across much of the country, a survey analysis has been done for that Financial Times last week suggested that in this key "red wall" seats Nothing has changed.

Despite a modest increase in polls since the leader switched to Keir Starmer, Labor remains in a purgatory with no clear way out, according to the British FPTP voting system.

Not viable

The bizarre decision to bring activists to Arfon was of course made by the Labor Party in London, as there is no Welsh Labor Party – it just doesn't exist, except as a trademark.

Don't take my word for it – Labor's own election report made it clear that the decision-makers in the election campaign had little understanding of Wales.

Where are Labor supporters in Wales? They stand at least five years ago by a right-wing British Tory government and probably more years without credible arguments to offer voters who hope for a better election, apart from Labor's election in the 2024 general election.

And Welsh Labor's belief that Westminster is the only way to socialism seems even less credible when you consider that a clear majority of Scottish voters support independence. It is a question of when rather than if The Scots are leaving, which means that Wales, thanks to its built-in majority in England, is sticking to permanent Tory rule.

The truth we all have to face is this: Labor's election in Westminster elections to maintain a socialist government is no longer viable. If politics is the art of the possible, it is high time that the Labor Party in Wales became aware of the fact that Westminster can no longer achieve this.

The earlier their leaders come to this realization, as a large and growing percentage of their own supporters have, the better.


Unfortunately, in the recent Senedd debate on independence, we only received the denial. In fact, the Labor MS who opposed the idea sounded very confused about the issue.

Mick Antoniv managed to claim that he believed in the "socialist principle", "that all nations have the right to self-determination". But he also said: "I am not a nationalist and reject nationalism as a negative and divisive ideology."

In fact, it's not an ideology at all – it's a position on the right to self-determination that he claims to believe in. Ironically, it is Labour's instinct that loyalty to Britain has to outdo everything else – even if it means ongoing goalkeeping – that is actually as "nationalistic" as the UKIP and the Brexit Party.

The dichotomy between socialism and nationalism created by Labor is wrong, although Wales' independence from Westminster is the only realistic route to socialism.

This confusion can also be seen elsewhere in the party. There is a group called Welsh Labor Grassroots who are clear about their goals as they call for a greater deviation from England in relation to Covid-19, but they are still affiliated with the British Labor Party and suggest Mick Antoniw is said to be Welsh Labor's voice in the NEC of the British Labor Party.

In the meantime, the Labor for a Independent Wales group has made further progress towards an inevitable outcome.

But they also have to recognize the paradox that while they are for an independent Wales, they are not even part of an independent Welsh Labor party. Until then, their position cannot be taken seriously.

The Labor Party has won every election in Westminster – and more recently in Senedd – in Wales for over 100 years. Even during this period, the argument that labor must be chosen to achieve socialism did not hold water, as Wales was led by the conservatives three quarters of the time, despite Labor's never-ending vote.

Now there is simply no basis at all to continue looking for power through Westminster. Welsh independence is the only way to socialism in Wales.

We can only hope that Labor will not need another 100 years to recognize this.

Source link

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.